Saucer Smear

OFFICIAL PUBLICATION OF THE SAUCER & UNEXPLAINED CELESTIAL EVENTS RESEARCH SOCIETY
EDITOR AND STILL
SUPREME COMMANDER:
James W. Moseley

CONTRIBUTING EDITOR:
Karl T. Pflock

NON-SCHEDULED
NEWSLETTER
Volume 51, No. 2
February 25th, 2004
(Whole Number 368)
OUR FIFTIETH YEAR!

MAILING ADDRESS:
P. 0. Box 1709
Key West, FL 33041

We welcome your correspondence, pro or con, well-reasoned or otherwise, but please keep in mind that while Saucer Smear is on the Dreaded Internet, your humble editor is NOT! So, if you wish to receive a personal reply to your letter, or wish to have any chance of seeing it printed on Our Glorious Pages, please print it out, put it in an envelope, affix a stamp thereto, and SNAIL mail it to:
James W. Moseley
P.O. Box 1709
Key West, FL 33041

It's simple and loads of fun! Ask your grandma if you don't remember how to do it!

We thank you!


TIDBITS OF TRASH


IN DEPTH DIATRIBES (a new category!)


CONVENTION ROUND-UP


Pflock Ptalk - JIM MCDONALD, WE HARDLY KNEW YE

by Karl Pflock, Our Contributing Editor & Fifth Columnist

Ann Drruffel's "Firestorm: Dr. James E. McDonald's Fight for UFO Science" (Wild Flower, 2003, trade paperback, $34.00) is an important book. It is also a significantly flawed book. Despite its shortcomings, it is must reading for anyone with a serious interest in ufology and a knowledge of The Field and its history that is both deep and broad, the only defense against becoming insnared by the errors of judgment and fact littering the book's 623 pages.

"Firestorm" is a sprawling, repetitive, undisciplined morass, in which is bogged down a first-class 350-or-so-page personal and intellectual biography. Druffel, a lovely lady and ufological pioneer, has been ill-served by her editors at Wild Flower. They did not exercise the tough love that is the stock and trade of all good book editors, firmly keeping their author focused on the inspiring and tragic story of a brilliant, quixotic man who attempted almost single-handedly, and in vain, to bootstrap ufology into scientific respectability.

Instead, they allowed Druffel to lard up her text with irrelevant and marginally relevant and lengthy asides and dark allusions to conspiracy and coverup, most aimed at suggesting the Silence Group/MJ-12/the CIA/Them hushed up McDonald and NICAP, the UFO organization with which he worked most closely, and perhaps even were somehow responsible for McDonald's self-inflicted (Druffel: ?) death in June 1971. A minor example of this, required to be mentioned here by the Truth in Book Reviewing Code, is her unquestioning repetition of the allegation that Yours Truly arguably was a CIA plant at NICAP Headquarters, a canard that originated with that paragon of truthtelling W. Todd Zechel, and was "sexed up" by the ufological gossip mill.

There also seems not to have been any consistent copyediting or fact checking applied, leading to such minor problems as Secretary of the Air Force Harold Brown being identified both correctly and as secretary of the army, and such very serious errors as this one: In text and a footnote on p. 60, Rcuffel asserts that in 1966 McDonald had been given official access to the still classified "Project Blue Book Special Report 14", for which she gives the wrong date and which she says McDonald discovered was in some important respects different from the declassified version published in 1976 by Leon Davidson. When I read this, I immediately realized something was amiss: "Special Report 14" had been declassified in 1955 and its essential elements first published by Davidson the following year. McDonald died in 1971. Hmmmm.. I contacted Druffel and learned that the classified document in question was, as I suspected, actually the infamous Robertson Panel Report.

Similarly, a good many of Druffel's summary accounts of UFO sightings are inaccurate or, worse, tricked out with bogus mystery. One such is her rendering of the Socorro, New Mexico, saucer (?) landing of April 1964. In addition to a number of factual errors and overstatements, she includes the clearly false claim that, almost immediately after Socorro policeman Lonnie Zamora reported his encounter, a specially equipped U.S. government vehicle showed up at the site and wiped it clean. She also finds something mysterious in the fact that one of the first persons on the scene was an FBI agent (the guy just happened to be at the town police station when Zamora called in).

Unfortunately, the foregoing examples are but the tip of the iceberg. Thus my warning that "Firestorm" isn't a book for the ufological un- and ill-informed. But then there is that first-class personal-intellectual biography trapped inside.

Druffel, with the help of a grant from the Fund for UFO Research, spent years archiving McDonald's UFO files and papers, now held at the University of Arizona library. Through this work and tireless pursuit of interviews with family, friends, and colleagues of McDonald, she has become the authority on the atmospheric physicist's remarkable quest to crack the UFO mystery and to get mainstream science to take the subject seriously.

In "Firestorm", Druffel gives us an often exciting and moving account of McDonald's efforts, which coincided with one of the most important periods in ufological history, a time when ufology probably had its one and last best shot at gaining scientific respectability. Among many other things of considerable interest, she reveals just how close McDonald came to being named to conduct a UFO study sponsored by the National Academy of Sciences, only to have this derailed by the air force decision to fund an "objective", "independent" university-based study, resulting in the Condon Committee fmasco. (Talk about an "if only..."!) She also establishes beyond any reasonable doubt that Phil Klass' charges that McDonald was misusing U.S. Navy contract monies for his personal UFO work were baseless and destructive misrepresentations. (Note to Gary Posner: Yes, she documents this.)

In sum, in recounting McDonald's personal struggle, Druffel portrays that of ufology at large and the clash of personalities and human foibles that have shaped our would--be science as we know it today.

In the course of this, we also come to know James McDonald as well as it may have been possible to know such a private person - difficult, single-minded, brilliant, abrasive, politically naive, and heroic. Ironically, those personal characteristics that gave him the courage to buck the scientific establishment and make such a major mark on and contribution to ufology seem also to have been the very factors that, along with the discrediting campaigns of such enemies as Klass and Donald Menzel, brought him up short of his goal.

If only...!


MISSIVES FROM THE MASSES


A Bristol man, caught with 17,000 worth of cannabis, convinced a jury it was for personal use. The man and his partner chain-smoked joints to relieve paranoia, agoraphobia, post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety and light sensitivity. His name was Christopher Blow. D. Mirror, 23 Nov 2002 LOST LUGGAGE RETURNS
A suitcase full of clothes belonging to a German hairdresser was lost by an airline after he went on holiday to Senegal in 1979. Twenty-four years later, in September 2003, it was found lying outside a police station in Dusseldorf. Where had it been? [R] 9 Sept 2003.
ALIENS A GAS
A man, his wife and daughter in Yukhnov, Russia, were amazed when a flying saucer appeared outside their window. The man called his teenage son to warn him not to come home as there were aliens outside. Sceptical, the young man came home anyway, to find gas pouring from the kitchen stove. A forgotten kettle had boiled over, putting out the flame. Doctors said the family had experienced a mass hallucination brought on by the gas. Ananova, 23 Oct 2003.
WILLIAM POTOGI, 33, WAS GIVEN A ritual bath by a witch doctor in Paramaribo, Surinam, to make him bullet-proof. He asked the witch doctor's assistant to test whether it had worked and was shot dead with his own sawn-off shotgun at point-blank range. According to Ronal Gayadhar, a policeman: "Both men deny murder and claim Potogi died because he lacked faith in the spell". [AFP] 5 Sept; Sun, 10 Sept 2002.


We guarantee that every dollar you donate to "Smear" will forever remain out of the hands of terrorists, anarchists, Free Thinkers, and other Undesirables! Every cent of your Donation will go to our own personal use, for necessities such as Scotch, Gin, Rum, and Coca-Cola. Make your check or money order out to the editor personally. Two E's in Moseley, please, though one will do!
Saucer Smear Index
Saucer Smear Mailbox
Please note that letters for Smear editor James Moseley should be snail-mailed to PO Box 1709, Key West, FL 33041, insofar as Cdr. Moseley is proudly computer-illiterate and determined to stay that way.

Own a genuine artifact of ufological history!
Line your birdcage for pennies a sheet!
Back issues available for the last 50 years!


HTML version by S L M